Ben Knapper.

morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Much maligned and used as a whipping boy for people's frustrations, but have you changed your opinion on him?

Have we actually built a decent squad, for this level?

Or would you still like him gone?
 
Fenway Frank

Fenway Frank

Well-Known Member
Every time something goes wrong it's knappers fault but no one seems to want to give him any credit when things are going well. He certainly isn't perfect but I think it would be hard to find someone better than him that would come here. Be careful what you wish for.
 
AyrshireBob

AyrshireBob

New Member
First off he was new to the this type of job. To be fair he has had some successful signings including I assume PC, and also had some poor signings.
But to be honest I don't think he has done that bad of a job. When you start a new job / role you are going to make mistakes but and it's a big but, you must learn from them, has Ben learnt buy his mistakes ?
Maybe just maybe and time will tell, looking at some of his signings over the last 12 months probably.
 
AmericanCanary

AmericanCanary

Member
He has steadily gotten better imo. As Bob said above, a job of this type is not easy at first but overall I think we have built a pretty competitive squad for this level at a decent financial pace also if you will. Like anything else mind, some fans sure still don't like the dude but that's how fans have been since the dawn of time.
 
B

Bill and ben

Member
He was a terrible appointment. Far too little relevant experience at a point when thats exactly what we needed. But I've no reason to think he is inherently bad and incapable of learning and growing. Lets judge him from here on
 
N

Nuff Said

Member
First of all, Knapper doesn’t scout, analyse, recommend and negotiate the signings all on his own. There are teams of people doing this, he is leading them but not individually responsible for every single decision. Some of them will have been in place before he arrived and probably will remain when he goes. As sporting director (or whatever he’s called), he ultimately carries the can for recruitment but it’s a team game.

Secondly, qualified by what I said above, signing Makama, Kvistgaarden and Toure within 12 months is a pretty impressive result.
 
Last edited:
N

Nuff Said

Member
Maybe one for the too dull for conversation thread, but how many ways can autocorrect spell Makama and still get it wrong?
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
First of all, Knapper doesn’t scout, analyse, recommend and negotiate the signings all on his own. There are teams of people doing this, he is leading them but not individually responsible for every single decision. Some of them will have been in place before he arrived and probably will remain when he goes. As sporting director (or whatever he’s called), he ultimately carries the can for recruitment but it’s a team game.

Secondly, qualified by what I said above, signing Makama, Kvistgaarden and Toure within 12 months is a pretty impressive result.
I think thats a pretty fair assesment. I used to cringe a bit when I heard fans chant "We want knapper out". I have always thought, even last season that we had bought some decent players.
 
Kevin the Cat

Kevin the Cat

New Member
I don't think he's a great leadership figure, something we lack in the club. The whole thing only works if we have a very strong manager. Any weakness there and we are f****d, as with Thorup and Manning. Brilliant to get Clement on board, an exceptional leader and authority figure but they are few and far between. I'd prefer an experienced football man in the SD post, not a stats man. Having said that, if we get promoted, keep him!
 
K

king harr

Member
I think thats a pretty fair assesment. I used to cringe a bit when I heard fans chant "We want knapper out". I have always thought, even last season that we had bought some decent players.
Yeah deffo ,there's plenty of talented players signed under knapper
 
K

king harr

Member
Of course there has been a couple of dud signings as there is in any club,but everyone loves a scapegoat !
 
F

Fen Canary

Active Member
Much maligned and used as a whipping boy for people's frustrations, but have you changed your opinion on him?

Have we actually built a decent squad, for this level?

Or would you still like him gone?
I still don’t think he’s built a particularly strong squad with the money he’s had to play with, not one that’s going to trouble the playoffs anyway. We’ve got some good strikers but are lacking in most other areas. We’ve got a good manager in Clement so he deserves credit if Knapper chose him, but he’s also picked also had two that didn’t do much beforehand.
For me his report card still has more marks against it than for it in my opinion.
 
K

king harr

Member
One of the big criticisms he had was the appointment of Liam manning but his managerial career was good,I was all for it but it didn't work out for a number of reasons ,bens a young guy with very little experience in that kind of role but he cares and is learning all the time !
 
N

Nuff Said

Member
One of the big criticisms he had was the appointment of Liam manning but his managerial career was good,I was all for it but it didn't work out for a number of reasons ,bens a young guy with very little experience in that kind of role but he cares and is learning all the time !
Agreed. The measure of a person or an organisation is not whether they are always right, but what they do when something does wrong. Are they open about their mistake and do they learn from it?
 
Monty13

Monty13

Active Member
I haven’t changed my mind because my opinion has pretty much always been he needed time to prove himself and what he’s proved is a mixed bag.

He's clearly got some massive calls wrong IMO. Last year when we were rock bottom I’d happily have seen him walk out the door with Manning.

I’m still unconvinced to be honest, he’s done a lot right after a sputtering start to his career but the start to this season has again put the focus back on his squad building.

Some feel good wins against some of the poorest opponents in the division does not change the fact that we still aren’t in the position we should be. Even though I think Clement holds a lot of the blame for a poor start, I can’t help but feel he’s still not got the squad composition right. Some good individual signings (and some poor over his time), but his job is to create a cohesive and complimentary squad.

Knapper needs to get us actually playoff competitive and keep us there beyond patches in a season before he earns genuine respect for his role IMO. He has my respect for turning it around from the Manning era though.
 
Kevin the Cat

Kevin the Cat

New Member
Agreed. The measure of a person or an organisation is not whether they are always right, but what they do when something does wrong. Are they open about their mistake and do they learn from it?
That's all very well, and he may well have grown into the role, but the question for me is that he was too inexperienced and shouldn't have been appointed in the first place, two years wasted while he learned the job. Having accepted that he is here and hopefully improving, it may be the best thing to keep him, but results are the key. Very good getting Clement, but pretty much went to him saying the club was in a mess and would he come and sort it out.
 
S

Sonyc

Well-Known Member
I haven’t changed my mind because my opinion has pretty much always been he needed time to prove himself and what he’s proved is a mixed bag.

He's clearly got some massive calls wrong IMO. Last year when we were rock bottom I’d happily have seen him walk out the door with Manning.

I’m still unconvinced to be honest, he’s done a lot right after a sputtering start to his career but the start to this season has again put the focus back on his squad building.

Some feel good wins against some of the poorest opponents in the division does not change the fact that we still aren’t in the position we should be. Even though I think Clement holds a lot of the blame for a poor start, I can’t help but feel he’s still not got the squad composition right. Some good individual signings (and some poor over his time), but his job is to create a cohesive and complimentary squad.

Knapper needs to get us actually playoff competitive and keep us there beyond patches in a season before he earns genuine respect for his role IMO. He has my respect for turning it around from the Manning era though.
Your last paragraph especially is the key for me. It's ultimately all about results. Jury out for me still. I've not been on one side or the other, though his silence during the earlier Manning period was infuriating.

His signings have been interesting and as ever some come off and some don't. If we become a solid play off team he will gain credit. Even then he needs a promotion on his CV.
 

Sit with the City fans who turn up

Free to join, free to read. Introduce yourself, pick a player thread, and get stuck into the next match thread.

Create a free account
Top