Din
Well-Known Member
To be honest Martin used to be a good right back. Throughout the Lambert years he was superb in all 3 divisions and for the next 2 years under Hughton he was decent, as was Whittaker, even though he was in and out of the side.
After we were relegated though and Neil Adams took over, Russell Martin decided that he wanted to be used as a centre back, and Adams (presumably wanting to keep his captain happy) obliged. Doing that completely ruined Martin. Even at Championship level he's not good enough to play centre back, and a lot of the time he looked out of his depth. Don't know what happened to him but doing that clearly just messed him up altogether because since then he's looked useless at right back as well, where he used to look very good. As for Whittaker, I can't even explain it seeing as he was decent for 2 years at right back under Hughton but has looked useless ever since despite playing the exact same position. He was consistantly 7 out of 10 under Alex Neil for half a season in the Championship, but that aside he has been absolutely woeful and has cost us God knows how many points and even Alex Neil who was a big fan of his in the Championship, worked out he was a liability and only played him a handful of times last season.
Neither player is good enough tbh. It's all too well as well keeping them as back-up, but what if Pinto next game gets and injury that rules him out for 6 months?
After we were relegated though and Neil Adams took over, Russell Martin decided that he wanted to be used as a centre back, and Adams (presumably wanting to keep his captain happy) obliged. Doing that completely ruined Martin. Even at Championship level he's not good enough to play centre back, and a lot of the time he looked out of his depth. Don't know what happened to him but doing that clearly just messed him up altogether because since then he's looked useless at right back as well, where he used to look very good. As for Whittaker, I can't even explain it seeing as he was decent for 2 years at right back under Hughton but has looked useless ever since despite playing the exact same position. He was consistantly 7 out of 10 under Alex Neil for half a season in the Championship, but that aside he has been absolutely woeful and has cost us God knows how many points and even Alex Neil who was a big fan of his in the Championship, worked out he was a liability and only played him a handful of times last season.
Neither player is good enough tbh. It's all too well as well keeping them as back-up, but what if Pinto next game gets and injury that rules him out for 6 months?