By using Norwichtalk.com services you agree to our Cookies Use and Data Transfer outside the EU.
We and our partners operate globally and use cookies, including for analytics, personalisation, ads and Newsletters.

Player ratings v Crawley

Agent Dale Cooper

Agent Dale Cooper

Active Member
Here's my take on tonight's performance:

Rudd 6. Looked a little unsure with high balls, made one great point-blank save near the end (I think, it was down the other end and it was a bit of a scramble!).

Martin 7. Typically solid back in his regular right-back role.

Cuellar 6. Looked very slow and ponderous on occasion, but that's to be expected after so long without a game. Made one excellent tackle near the end of the first half when a foul would have been a penalty and a red card, and made a couple of excellent blocks.

McFadden 7. Did really well for a debutant. Took no risks and read the game well. Got outmuscled by McLeod a bit, but that was to be expected as he's a real handful.

Whittaker 6. A mixed bag. Was a bit careless in possession but had a stronger second half.

Josh Murphy 8. Two excellent goals and an energetic performance; still a bit naive in possession on occasion, but certainly looked like a real threat for most of the game.

Surman 6. Playing alongside Elliott Bennett in the centre wasn't ideal for either player, as neither is a natural ball winner. Gave possession away a few times but looked neat and tidy when he dropped deeper to collect the ball.

E Bennett 6. Decent shift considering he was playing out of position, but as mentioned above he wasn't helped by the absence of a natural ball-winner.

Jacob Murphy 5. Tried a couple of early flicks that didn't come off, and generally looked pretty poor I felt.

Jamar Loza 7. Didn't create a huge amount, but his tireless running and pressing when we didn't have the ball impressed me. Doubt he'll get much game time in the league, but seemed desperate to impress and really put a shift in. Should have scored at the end when he hit the post.

Cameron Jerome 7. Got the easiest goal he'll ever score presented to him on a plate. You could see from his runs off the ball that he is an intelligent striker, and put himself about a lot. When he gets fully fit I think he'll be a great addition to the squad.

Subs: Hall-Johnson 5. Didn't get much of the ball, and when he did get it he seemed reluctant to do anything positive with it. I think nerves may have got the better of him.

Becchio - only played 10 minutes or so, so unfair to give him a rating really. Didn't do a great deal, although he did have a comedy foot-race with 'The Beast' Jensen near the end which was worth the entry fee on its own :)

Overall there wasn't much cohesion, but that's to be expected with so many changes. I think Adams could have changed things a bit when Crawley were getting the upper hand midway through the second half; personally I'd have brought Johnson on for the last 20 to shore things up and moved Bennett out wide. It was more by luck than judgement that we held on to the lead. Even so, we're in the hat and we still have our big names fresh for Saturday. Job done.
 
BarclayBoy88

BarclayBoy88

New Member
Would agree with most of that, would say:

McFadden - 6 (Know it was his debut, but I think that showed how far away he is from the first team)

E.Bennett - 5 (Thought he was really poor, but he's not a central midfielder, gave the ball away a lot)

J. Loza -8 (Thought he was really tidy, ran at the defense with intent, strong, fast, two footed, very good)

I would say overall it's a case of job done. Josh Murphy and Jamar Loza were the pick of the bunch for me, Jerome needs to up his work rate and Whittaker just needs to be replaced in the first team. 
 
Agent Dale Cooper

Agent Dale Cooper

Active Member
I guess it's a case of expectation. If Martin had put McFadden's performance in at CB tonight then he'd have rightly been criticised, but to stick an untried teenager alongside a slow, unfit journeyman at centre half was asking for trouble really. That considered, I thought the lad did pretty well. As the game went on he was increasingly desperate to ensure he didn't make any big mistakes, so adopted an extremely 'safety first' approach and put the ball in the stand rather than trying to play his way out of trouble. Considering the circumstances, I think that was the right thing to do.

In other news, anyone know why he was selected ahead of Gafaiti, who wasn't in the squad? Has he snuck off on loan while I wasn't looking?
 
BarclayBoy88

BarclayBoy88

New Member
I don't think he was bad, but for a centre half I don't think we can expect him to break through any time soon. Didn't win anything in the air, wasn't particularly fast or tidy on the ball, I thought his positioning really needed some work and he panicked a few times. He put the ball behind for a corner where he could have easily just booted it upfield and they almost scored from that corner. Maybe being a bit harsh on the lad as it was his first start and he was playing alongside Cuellar who looked extremely rusty. Will be going to most U21 home games this year so can see how he progresses. He may well get a start in round three as well, so lets hope for a home tie. 
 
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
Jerome needs to up his work rate and Whittaker just needs to be replaced in the first team. 
Jerome is well known for having a high work rate so that observation must mean he has a lot of lost ground to make up fitness wise.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
BarclayBoy88

BarclayBoy88

New Member
Jerome is well known for having a high work rate so that observation must mean he has a lot of lost ground to make up fitness wise.
Absolutely, I may have worded that wrong. He ran a lot tonight, did a lot of closing down, but didn't really seem to want to challenge for many balls, as a strong, powerful lad, I wanted to see him put his body in-between the ball and the defender and hold it up, and also go up in the air and challenge. He seemed reluctant to do that tonight, that's more what I meant rather than he was lazy in general. Poor wording on my behalf really. 
 
Agent Dale Cooper

Agent Dale Cooper

Active Member
I don't think he was bad, but for a centre half I don't think we can expect him to break through any time soon. Didn't win anything in the air, wasn't particularly fast or tidy on the ball, I thought his positioning really needed some work and he panicked a few times. He put the ball behind for a corner where he could have easily just booted it upfield and they almost scored from that corner. Maybe being a bit harsh on the lad as it was his first start and he was playing alongside Cuellar who looked extremely rusty. Will be going to most U21 home games this year so can see how he progresses. He may well get a start in round three as well, so lets hope for a home tie. 
Yeah that slice behind for a corner near the end looked pretty desperate. I'm not suggesting he's anywhere near ready for the first team, just that he did reasonably well considering. To be fair Cuellar didn't win much in the air either, they put everything towards McLeod who is a real unit - strong and with a great leap on him.
 
J

Josh

New Member
Right, lets go:

Rudd - 7. Couple of smart stops, including a very good one from a late corner. 

Martin - 6. Fine. Not bad, not great, wasn't overly exposed but didn't offer much either. Felt like he was going through in 2nd gear to not do any damage to himself or get knackered.

Whittaker - 6. As above.

Cuellar - 4. Bad. Lack of pace is a worry but given he hasn't played for months, alongside a kid making his debut and a team he's never played for before, it was never going to be great. I'd base it all on rust but his speed is something to keep an eye on.

McFadden - 7. For a player making his debut he was good. I liked the fact he was taking control, dictating where the defensive line should be. Promising.

Surman - 5. Poor. Bad passing.

Bennett - 5. Poor. Not a central midfielder. 

Jacob Murphy - 7. No worse than Josh for the time he was on the pitch, beauty of a crossfield ball for the second goal, did fine. A couple of loose passes and tricks didn't come off. Needs to learn there's a time and place. But he was pretty good.

Josh Murphy - 8. Got better, the final goal was a great finish. Strangely I thought he lacked a bit, but he still could beat his man whenever he wanted, could've had another goal, set up a few chances. Got more confident as it went on.

Jerome - 8. Strong. Smart striker, got into good positions, could've had another if he'd been found in a good position 2nd half. He's going to be a better option up front than Grabban soon enough. 

Loza - 6. A couple of smart link up movements but offered not a lot. Can learn a lot from Jerome for how to go up against defenders, find space, offer options etc. 

RHJ - 5. Didn't do much. 

Becchio - didnt really get on the pitch for long enough to impact. 
 
BarclayBoy88

BarclayBoy88

New Member
Yeah that slice behind for a corner near the end looked pretty desperate. I'm not suggesting he's anywhere near ready for the first team, just that he did reasonably well considering. To be fair Cuellar didn't win much in the air either, they put everything towards McLeod who is a real unit - strong and with a great leap on him.
Yeah that is definitely fair enough. I will say that if you were asked which centre half was making his debut and which one had over 5 years premier League experience, I think you'd struggle. Sure he was nervous and sure he'll improve with time, he's only young and good to see him out there. Next to someone like Turner, he probably would have looked better.  
 
Agent Dale Cooper

Agent Dale Cooper

Active Member
Jacob Murphy - 7. No worse than Josh for the time he was on the pitch, beauty of a crossfield ball for the second goal, did fine. A couple of loose passes and tricks didn't come off. Needs to learn there's a time and place. But he was pretty good.
Hadn't realised it was Jacob who played that great diagonal ball to Josh for our second goal - I wasn't paying attention. Looking at where on the pitch the pass was hit from, I assumed it was Martin who played the switch. Fair play to the lad if that's the case, that pass was worth a point on its own :)

Edit: hang on a minute, you're not actually Josh Murphy are you, and just trying to big up your brother? ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yellow Fever

Yellow Fever

New Member
Having watched the Youth team on occasions, the two Murphys do seem to have a special understanding and "that great diagonal ball to Josh for our second goal" was a perfect example of that. IMO, there's a lot of potential building with these two and in other younger players. Great to see.
 
skijumptoes

skijumptoes

Active Member
Yeah watching the youth team it was blatantly obvious they're on the same wavelength even when at opposite ends of the pitch.  Jacob's ball last night was a really painful one to deal with as he gave it so much lift the bounce was always going to be awkward... What i have noticed with Josh is his ability to let the ball do the work and uses it's movement to commit the defender, it's only when they move in on what looks like a 50/50 ball he's there to shift it away.  You can't teach that, it's a natural desire he has to outfox and play with defenders.

When he's got the ball he's constantly touching it which is key in getting defenders backing off from you,  Great talent.

What will be interesting, and i've not seen him do it a lot is how he can bring a ball down and have it under control in tight situations and how he will deal with defenders who are able to make it look like they're committing in one direction but are ready for him to go the other way, at that point the defender can call the shots.

Great to watch battles like that unfold over a game as you can see the bluffs and double bluffs building up, and ultimately can end up with the defender totally legless and skinned.  It's my favourite part of the beautiful game.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
M

Mundham

New Member
Jerome - 8. Strong. Smart striker, got into good positions, could've had another if he'd been found in a good position 2nd half. He's going to be a better option up front than Grabban soon enough. 

The same Grabban who is scoring for fun both last season and this?
 
Top